Paul Miller

Odd as it may seem, this question arose during my preparation for yesterday’s conversation with True Knowledge CEO, William Tunstall-Pedoe. You see, one of the demonstrations of True Knowledge’s capabilities takes the form of a local product search that looks – superficially – a lot like Google’s better known Local offering.

Searching for pizza in Google returns exactly what I’ve become accustomed to; a badly incomplete list of pizza restaurants and take aways. My initial presumption was that True Knowledge would do something pretty similar, maybe with the added smarts to find a few more establishments that didn’t explicitly say ‘pizza’ in their name or description.

I presumed wrongly. Instead, True Knowledge returned a pretty comprehensive list of shops that sell pizza; right down to the pokey little ones attached to petrol stations. I’m impressed by the comprehensiveness, and I’m impressed by the reasoning involved in working out that supermarkets like Netto or Morrisons sell pizza.

Comprehensiveness and computational cleverness aside, the stark differences in interpretation of my intention strike me as interesting; is either more ‘right?’ And if we assume, for a moment, that True Knowledge is the one that got it right, does that matter when practically everyone has become conditioned to expect the interpretation Google used?

I did raise this with William during our call, and some of his thoughts on the matter are worth hearing.

What do you think?

Pizza image by ‘wEnDaLicious,’ shared on Flickr under a Creative Commons license.

Related articles by Zemanta

• Local Listings Come to Google Street View (marketingpilgrim.com)
• Universal Answer Engine (arnoldit.com)
• Semantic Search Round Table at the Semantic Technology Conference (blogs.zdnet.com)